वेदान्त पारिजात सौरभ (भगवद् निम्बार्काचार्य - द्वैताद्वैत वेदान्त ब्रह्मसूत्र भाष्य सटीक)
Vedanta Parijata Saurabha of Nimbarkacharya with Commentary
भगवद् निम्बार्काचार्य (टीकाकार: श्रीश्रीनिवासचार्य - वेदान्तकौस्तुभ सहित) द्वारा
पृष्ठ 426, कुल 906 में से
संदर्भ में पढ़ें[sū. 2. 3. 15
406 VEDĀNTA-KAUSTUBHA ADH. 6.]
(We reply.) “No”. Why ? “On account of non-difference,”
i.e. because of the non-difference of the origin of knowledge and mind,
as well as of the ether and the rest, from Brahman alone. The text:
‘From him arise the vital-breath’ (Muṇḍ. 2 1 3) and so on simply
points out that there is the origin of all from Brahman, and is not set
aside by the above-mentioned order. In the very same manner,
scriptural texts like: ‘He created the vital-breath, from the vital-
breath reverence, the ether, the air, the fire, water, the earth, the sense-
organs, the mind, food’ (Praśna 6.4) and so on, designate that every-
thing arises from Brahman, and do not set forth a particular order.
The meaning of the word ‘vital-breath’ in the passage. ‘From him
arise the vital-breath, the mind and all sense-organs’ (Muṇḍ. 2.1.3)
will become clear later on.¹ And, thus it is established that in the
aphorism. “But there is” (Br. Sū. 2 3 2), only a portion (of the real
order of creation) has been mentioned by the author of the aphorisms.
So, in the abridged texts designating the order of the origination of
elements, such as: ‘From the soul the ether originated’ (Tait. 2.1)
and so on, the portions not mentioned, viz. prakṛti, mahat and the
rest, established by other texts concerned about creation and dissolu-
tion, and figuratively implied by the phrase “knowledge and mind”
(in the sūtra), are necessarily understood; but there is no contradiction
whatsoever of the texts designating the order of the origination of
elements by other texts.
Here ends the section entitled “Knowledge which intervenes” (6).
COMPARISON
Śaṃkara
The interpretation of the word “aviśeṣāt” different, viz. “On
account of the non-difference (of the organs from the elements)”.
That is, the organs being of the same nature as the elements, the
origination of the former is the same as that of the latter, and not
different.²
¹ Vide Br. Sū. 2.4.9.
² Ś.B. 2.3.15, p. 602.